What a lovely ride this one. Enjoyful for the action and dystopia alonne, this one also adds quite the deep subtext in philosophy, grammar, linguistics, all of it. Frankly, i'm not even sure the story would be that terrible of a future; Sure it's devoid of many of the amenities we have right now, but the neigh anarchic structure does seem to work quite well.
The way the automation, say the librarion, work are quite interesting. They speak, but don't think. Current LLM research tends to show how much of thought directly transfers from speech: Metaphors, relationships, higher order function. It's motivated me to look into religion more as well, we see if I get to read some scripture in due time.
This was truly an incredible read. Did not expect to enjoy a relatively old book on the history of science as much as I did. It focuses on big innovators (notably Newton, Lavoisier, Einstein and Maxwell) and uses their historic positions to illustrate his points clearly. It's about as page-turny as such a book can get.
It's influence, both wrt content and linguistically is immense. Just so that terms like "paradigm shift" have taken on a life of their own and changed much from their original meaning.
Much of what kuhn describes, students becoming scientists, has lost itself in college politics and bureaucracy. The most innovative fields like CS ahve their research done in large parts by private companies. Will be interesting to see where the next paradigm shift brings us to.
Book runs you through most of early CS math, with a special focus on Russell’s principles, as well as Gödel and Hilbert. Turing’s work is discussed from a solution to first-order predicate logic, less from an engineering viewpoint.
Excellent to review the fundamentals and to grasp the essence of the proofs involved in the process. I especially enjoyed the section on the discussion of the halting problem, as well as the uniting of λ-calculus with the Turing machine.
Not all is positive; sometimes the comments seem to add little value to the descriptions as provided by Turing. A more modern approach could rehash this with modern programming concepts, making it more relatable, but would lose much of the appeal of following this through Turing’s lens.
All in all, recommended reading, but by no means necessary.
This was not an easy book to get through. One is often bewildered by the extent of the depravity of a system predicated upon evil. Such a system does not propagate via evil men, but via cowards, second handers and those happy to simply follow orders. But one notices that similarly, bravery can be extracted from everyone. Collective action against totalitarianism has brought real actionable results.
The world is built by those who improve it, Genius raises us further than evil could hope to push us down. The threat of totalitarianism is omnipresent, but the goal maximum liberty. It’s the goal all society will eventually converge to.